Sunday, November 15, 2026

Primetime

Director: Lance Oppenheim
Starring: Robert Pattinson, Merritt Wever, Skyler Gisondo, Matthew Maher, Phoebe Bridgers, Bokeem Woodbine, Alex Winter, Tony Revolori, Bob Ari, Jonathan Lipnicki, Matt Smith, Anna Faris, Caroline Hebert, Eric Rahill
Running Time: 109 min.
Rating: R

★★★ ½ (out of ★★★★) 

It's almost impossible to believe NBC's To Catch A Predator ran only three seasons since the show's impact, legacy and influence on the media landscape would have you thinking it lasted twice that. At the time, it sure felt longer, as Dateline correspondent Chris Hansen's popular news magazine segment saw him trapping online predators and child abusers in televised sting operations. And it's hard to deny a real sense of justice came from watching the worst of the worst get their comeuppance in front of millions every week when Hansen entered those kitchens to interrogate them.  

As the series wore on, the predators featured grew even more depraved, upping the audience's satisfaction when they're tackled to the ground by law enforcement after the decoy exits. But given how huge the show became, it's still amazing just how little we knew beyond what aired. That changes with director Lance Oppenheim's jaw dropping and controversial Primetime, which doesn't only explore the events leading to the show's eventual demise, but the downward trajectory of a host who believed his own hype to the very end.

It's 2006 and Dateline NBC's Chris Hansen (Robert Pattinson) hosts To Catch a Predator, which lures child predators to houses where they expect to engage in sex with minors. Instead, they encounter an adult decoy before Hansen drops in with his camera crew and they're arrested. With help from no-nonsense producer Andie Bender (Merritt Weaver), Perverted-Justice founder Xavier Von Erck (Matthew Maher) and decoy Del Harvey (Phoebe Bridgers), Hansen's show becomes a runaway success, prompting studio head Jeff Zucker to program it in primetime opposite ABC's Lost. As they prepare for the big move, aspiring actor Dan Plum (Skyler Gisondo) signs on as their newest decoy, hoping to use the show as a stepping stone to a SAG card. Unfortunately, he hasn't a clue what he's just gotten himself into.   

While the egomaniacal Hansen takes Dan under his wing, his extramarital affair with a younger woman surfaces, putting the host's carefully calculated public image in jeopardy. As network pressure mounts and Andie contemplates leaving, an opportunity arises for the show's biggest sting yet when Xavier locates a potential pedophile in Texas holding a high government position. Convinced he's found their "whale," Hansen ignores Andie's objections, pouring all their resources into an operation that could either save or destroy the show they've worked so hard to build. 

As little as we know about what unfolded behind the scenes, it's still more than we've ever heard about the mastermind behind it. Because of that, the film could double as a Chris Hansen biopic, at least as far as you're willing to believe this extreme depiction bares a close enough resemblance to who he was. But with a Pattinson performance this brilliantly disturbing, that shouldn't matter to anyone but the real Hansen, who's vigorously disputed a portrayal that does him few favors, even threatening legal action over his portrayal. 

Besides being a key screen presence for these stings, Hansen has his hand in every aspect of Predator's production, pouring over the tiniest details to ensure its continued resonance. It's also not a stretch to call him a hero, using this enormous platform to keep children safe and put these likely offenders behind bars. But Oppenheim and writer Ajon Singh creatively dramatize these events to show the uglier side of heroism, making a far more compelling case than if they stuck strictly to the facts.  

Directing his first narrative feature, acclaimed documentarian Oppenheim shoots it similarly, giving this a saturated analog look that visually mirrors TV's reality era of the mid-2000's. He also isn't afraid to take a creative license with Hansen's increasingly unhinged behavior. Fancying himself less a journalist than the crusading savior of abused and exploited children, he basks in the fans' adulation, especially during an early airplane scene that first exposes us to his performative grandstanding. 

At points, Hansen is so arrogantly self-centered that those closest to him need frequent reminders of the mission in order to look past his behavior. And he's quick to provide it, while Pattinson commits to projecting a slimy, unlikable philanderer who picks fame over his neglected wife Mary Joan (played by Anna Faris) and their two kids. In a film full of oddly inspired casting, he's the oddest, once again showing he can pretty much do anything. 

Pattinson goes all in, uncannily mimicking Hansen's voice and confronting would be predators like a stern, disapproving dad. With online chat transcripts in hand, he reads them their creepiest lines, just so they can hear exactly who they are. From all this, it's clear Hansen takes his job very seriously, even if the show doesn't, treating the worst crimes imaginable as comical gotchas and hidden camera gags. 

Few experience the brunt of this as much as Dan, who plays "bait" in a handful of carefully orchestrated scenarios. In an unsung performance, Skyler Gisondo tackles a role within a role as this twenty something who dreams of starring in movie musicals, only to become the butt of a nationwide joke. While portraying 13-year-olds for mere minutes of screen time isn't the acting credit he envisioned, it's also humiliating, not to mention extremely dangerous. Sucked into Hansen's vortex, he's transfixed by his pitch of the show cleansing the world of an ancient evil, which comes across as a delusional urban legend the host keeps convincing himself is true.

As a fictitious composite of the show's many producers, Merritt Weaver's Andie is the only person capable of controlling this chaos and tolerating Hansen's unpredictability. Born to do it and somewhat ashamed there's no one better, she entertains a change in scenery, wondering if a more positive work environment could rub off on her. But she's gone too far to turn back, with Hansen's team inching closer to capturing his elusive "whale," a quest she rightly suspects will end in disaster. But more surprising than what eventually transpires is the actor chosen for that pivotal role, assuming you recognize him.  

Multiple things are true at once. Chris Hansen can be viewed as a hero who prevents crimes against kids, but also a malignant narcissist reminiscent of American Psycho's Patrick Batman. The show can provide a valuable public service while at the same time enriching clueless, overpaid studio executives who don't really believe in it. Oppenheim isn't vilifying a flawed Hansen's positive contributions so much as recognizing those who do good aren't always wearing capes or walking around in shiny armor. 

Similarly, any criticisms of the show's concept don't stem from its results, but a reality circus where some willing participants end up suffering more than the pedophiles. Though its effectiveness as a giant net for catching criminals is unmatched, we'd be kidding ourselves by pretending that goal wasn't ranked a distant fourth to money, ratings and entertainment. It's probably worth the trade-off, but at least Primetime gets credit for acknowledging a conversation that's still worth having. 

No comments: