Director: Lee Kirk
Starring: Mason Thames, Kylr Coffman, Ryan Foust, Jenna Fischer, Mckenna Grace, Angela Kinsey, Keen Ruffalo, Ignacio Diaz-Silverino, Billie Joe Armstrong, Mike Dirnt, Tré Cool, Harper Marie Kirk, Fred Armisen, Bobby Lee, Sean Gunn, Jolene Blalock
Running Time: 107 min.
Rating: R
★★★ (out of ★★★★)
Bands like Kiss and the Foo Fighters may have tried first, but it's still only natural Green Day gets a movie that revolves around their music, or rather the experience of being a fan of it. And if you can say anything about writer/director Lee Kirk's surprisingly enjoyable road trip comedy Nimrods, it's that it looks and feels as if it was made in the 90's, complete with an Empire Records-like vibe fans of this genre should appreciate. The only catch is its story doesn't actually take place during that period, but a sort of retro 2026.
Of course, the biggest motivator for setting this in the present is to fit the full breadth of Green Day's decades spanning catalogue onto the soundtrack. So while it may have made more sense for this to be set in the mid to late 90's Dookie era, there's still a well intentioned effort from Kirk to recreate that through certain aesthetic and stylistic choices. The approach also earns high marks for not making everything "about" Green Day, despite the plot's inspiration coming from their early days traveling to gigs in a van. Or in this case, a stolen cab and broken down ice cream truck.
It's December 20th and best friends Tommy (Mason Thames) and Fred (Kylr Coffman) ditch school before going on winter break, dedicating their free time to rehearsing with shy, sheltered drummer Chad (Ryan Foust) in their unfortunately named band, Analog Dogs. And though they dream of hitting it big like their idols Green Day, Tommy feuds with dismissive older brother Wayne (Keen Ruffalo) as mom Jodie (Jenna Fischer) continues to grieve the boys' late father.
With Tommy and Fred desperate to see their favorite band in concert, Wayne and and his manic best friend Keith (Ignacio Diaz-Silverino) play a phone prank convincing them the Analog Dogs have been chosen to open for Green Day's New Year's Eve show in L.A based on a submitted demo. Believing this, Tommy, Fred and a reluctant Chad steal Wayne's car to get there, getting into numerous misadventures as Tommy bonds with free spirited rocker Olivia (Mckenna Grace) along the way. But the real challenge isn't just getting to the show, but also somehow proving they belong.
That you'd swear these events don't take place now is one of the film's most endearing qualities, invoking a real throwback quality that pays homage to teen road trip comedies of a similar vein, especially since the plot's catalyst is a band whose music helped define its time. And given their continued longevity, an argument could easily be made for them being overdue for such a treatment. But the real stars are this ragtag group of likable burnouts who appear to have walked straight off the set of Freaks and Geeks.
The Black Phone's Thames is the most recognizable in the cast, effectively playing Tommy as the sympathetic protagonist and underdog dreamer of the group. Having lost a parent, all his focus shifts to Analog Dogs, often at the expense of school and an already strained, uncommunicative relationship with a hardly blameless older brother. Kylr Coffman's Fred provides most of the broadest comedy with such wide-eyed, inexplicable reactions to the chaos you'd assume he's just high all the time. So much so that when he actually does take shrooms in a memorably trippy sequence, you'll wonder how any of them can tell.
Ryan Foust has maybe the strongest sub-plot as a petrified Chad, who's always on the verge of quitting, struggling to overcome the fear and insecurity instilled in him by a loony, overprotective mom (Jolene Blalock). As Olivia, Mckenna Grace is a delight, sharing effortless chemistry with Thames that suits the story and never seems forced. Ruffalo's turn as big brother Wayne peaks late but arrives at an interesting, affecting place after he and Keith decide to trail the guys out to L.A.
Many of the jokes and gags land, whether it's an uncomfortably awkward stop at a biker bar or their stay in a roadside motel with a creepy manager (a hilarious Fred Armisen) who puts Norman Bates to shame. We're not given much of a read on Analog Dogs' talent aside from a couple of brief performances, but that hardly matters when Green Day's music does most of the heavy lifting. From Dookie to Insomniac to Warning and right through American Idiot and 21st Century Breakdown, it's a lot. And this isn't even including the unreleased live and exclusive tracks that fill out the rest of a soundtrack that climaxes with their biggest mainstream hit, and one befitting the film's conclusion.
Using Green Day's songs as a storytelling anchor for these fictional characters we grow to care about was a smart way to approach this. And given the band's presence as credited producers and writers on the project, it's easy to believe they had some amount of creative sway in how this played out. The curiously backwards aging Billie Joe Armstrong, Tré Cool and Mike Dirnt all make brief, entirely functional appearances as themselves, ceding the spotlight to their fictional counterparts despite the wall-to-wall presence of their music.
While the soundtrack could border on overkill for some and less might have amounted to more, Kirk earns an easy pass by doing his main job exceptionally well. Plus, it's just downright comical imagining anyone infuriated by too much Green Day given what they signed up for. So even if it's a stretch their shows would still attract an audience this young, the fun comes in entering an alternate present where that's entirely possible. You can tell it knows enough to put them at the center of their own universe, but with humility, which is all fans really want from a movie featuring their favorite band. And by wisely going a few steps further, Nimrods also reaches more casual viewers looking for their own nostalgia fix.







