Yellowjackets (Season 1)

Creators: Ashley Lyle and Bart Nickerson
Starring: Melanie Lynskey, Tawny Cypress, Ella Purnell, Sophie Nélisse, Jasmin Savoy Brown, Sophie Thatcher, Samantha Hanratty, Steven Krueger, Warren Kole, Christina Ricci, Juliette Lewis, Courtney Eaton, Liv Hewson, Kevin Alves, Rekha Sharma, Jane Widdop, Sarah Desjardins, Rukiya Bernard, Aiden Stoxx, Peter Gadiot, Alex Wyndham
Original Airdate: 2021 

★★★ ½ (out of ★★★★)  

Lost meets Lord of the Flies in Showtime's Yellowjackets, which already managed to stand out as a major achievement in an increasingly crowded TV field. But what's most intriguing about this psychological thriller created by Ashley Lyle and Bart Nickerson is how it superficially appears to be taking us down a familiar road, before developing its premise in increasingly inventive ways that set it apart. At this point, the "mystery box" genre is basically an art form unto itself, often accompanied by demanding viewers' fears they'll only get burned in the end. And that's a real risk here, as questions and plots continue to accumulate, possibly increasing the odds of eventual frustration. Then again, maybe not. 

Considering how much is still likely to come, it's worth stopping to appreciate a series that feels as if its potential is limitless. And judging this season in a vacuum, freed from expectations of what's next, it's pretty astounding. While a truly accurate verdict can only come once the succeeding chapters play out, it's still impossible no to revel in its addictiveness. Whether or not this is the high water mark, when you get a ten episodes this meticulously constructed and suspenseful, the optimism feels warranted. 

Straddling two timelines, the show invites a rewatch for clues and details that could easily go unnoticed the first go-around. A chilling, occasionally gory survival tale and darkly comical coming-of-age story, it's most interested in how one event can leave lasting emotional trauma that shapes and scars its survivors well into adulthood. And in reframing the idea of what actually constitutes "surviving," it also provides some underappreciated 90's actresses the best roles of their careers, while being backed by a lineup of younger talents who match them at every turn. With a killer soundtrack and unmatched eye for period detail, it's a throwback that's also timely, digging deeply into current culture's true crime obsession.

It's 1996 when a plane carrying the Wiskayok, New Jersey high school girl's yellowjackets soccer team crashes in the Canadian wilderness en route to nationals in Seattle. They'll be stranded for 19 months, scouring for food and struggling to stay alive, holding out hope for a rescue that doesn't look imminent. Among the survivors are team captain and popular queen bee Jackie (Ella Purnell), her best friend Shauna (Sophie Nélisse), stubborn, super-competitive Taissa (Jasmin Savoy Brown), class burnout Natalie (Sophie Thatcher), wisecracking goalkeeper Van (Liv Hewson), schizophrenic Lottie (Courtney Eaton), devoutly religious Laura Lee (Jane Widdop) bullied, awkward equipment manager Misty (Samantha Hanratty) assistant coach Ben (Steven Krueger) and Travis (Kevin Alves) and younger brother Javi (Luciano Leroux), sons of Coach Martinez (Carlos Sanz), who perished in the crash. As winter approaches and the need for food becomes increasingly urgent, tensions bubble over, fragmenting the group. With the woods possibly holding some dark secrets of its own, it's heavily hinted they may soon be resorting to cannibalism to survive.

In present day, we meet the yellowjackets as middle-aged adults when they start receiving mysterious postcards marked with a familiar symbol, reuniting them to protect the secret of what really happened in the woods 25 years earlier. An impulsive Shauna (Melanie Lynskey) feels trapped in a sexless marriage with Jackie's ex-boyfriend Jeff (Warren Kole) when she's approached by suspicious reporter Jessica Roberts (Rekha Sharma), who's attempting to extract information about the crash. 

Taissa (Tawny Cypress) is running for state senator while trying to keep her family out of the public fray. Fresh out of rehab and struggling with her sobriety, Natalie (Juliette Lewis) attempts to locate recently missing ex-boyfriend Travis with geriatric nurse and self-proclaimed "citizen detective" Misty's (Christina Ricci) help. Clingy as ever and still desperately trying to be liked and accepted by the group, there's little she won't do to solve this mystery. With the crash's effects still impacting their lives, finally facing the truth might be the only way out. Unless a threatening blackmailer exposes it first.

Flashbacks and video footage are utilized in showing the public attention the accident has gotten, while we meet the team in the days leading up to the '96 crash. There's a heavy focus on Jackie, who's anointed team captain more for her influence over the others than soccer skills or leadership abilities. Her close friendship with sidekick Shauna seems partially built on a power dynamic that keeps Jackie  the center of attention as she runs around with Jeff (Jack DePew). But there's this subtle tension between the two girls you sense early on, as well as a gigantic secret that completely alters their relationship once the accident occurs, prompting Shauna step out of her friend's shadow. Physically and emotionally suffering in the wild, Jackie's social standing proves irrelevant when pushed this far outside her comfort zone.

With Taissa emerging as the group's leader, previously ostracized Mindy proves medically invaluable in the wilderness. And she knows it, the satisfaction of being needed causing her more manipulative, sociopathic tendencies to surface (like an obsession with Coach Ben). Samantha Hanratty is revelation in the role, which becomes even more apparent when you take Ricci's performance into account as the adult version.

Plagued by substance abuse and a rough upbringing, Natalie unexpectedly bonds with a very distant Travis. And off her medication, Lotti is having eerily prescient visions that are rapidly separating the believers from everyone else. That these sub-plots aren't entirely divorced from real teen problems in the 90's give them even more weight, as many of them were already bubbling under the surface before that fated flight took off.

Perceived pecking orders and hierarchies are flipped once everyone's thrown into a do-or-die scenario that exposes their strengths and weaknesses. It's not surprising things get ugly fast, but the series excels most in depicting the tiny, uncomfortable details that aren't talked about or don't initially come to mind when considering the challenges of being stranded in the woods with no help in sight. 

Credit the makeup and effects team for believably depicting some gruesome deaths and injuries that only intensify in number as this wears on. If episode 7 ("No Compass") contains the season's scariest and most shocking event, tensions reach a peak in the ninth ("Doomcoming"), when the group trips on hallucinogenic shrooms, causing all hell to break loose. What happens next ensures there's no turning back from the darkness. Some will embrace that, even as others don't.  

Ella Purnell's complicated and nuanced performance as outgoing, insecure "mean girl" Jackie creates somewhat of a dilemma since she's the lead and her character isn't seen in present day.  That we immediately assume the worst only increases the intrigue level, prompting speculation as to whether the writers would actually kill off such a major player this early. And if so, why? While there's a genuine sense no one is safe, many reasons work in explaining why we haven't met certain adult versions of the girls. At least as of yet. Everything's on the table, with the only guarantee being that the worst is certainly still ahead. 

All the older actresses are accurate ringers for their younger counterparts in looks, demeanors and personalities, so even as Jackie's future absence remains conspicuous, Shauna, Taissa, Natalie and Misty more than carry the load. Stuck in a state of arrested development, Shauna has a terrible relationship with her rebellious daughter Callie (Sarah Desjardins) and in therapy with husband Jeff when she embarks on an affair with the younger Adam (Peter Gadiot). A suspicious artist who happens to land in her life just as the yellowjackets are being blackmailed, he immediately sends up all sorts of red flags. 

Lynskey carries much of the present day story and it might go unnoticed just how consistently effective she is in playing a woman so used to burying her trauma that she can hardly recognize herself anymore. Based on recent life choices, guilt-ridden Shauna should be the the series' most unlikable character, but in Lynskey's capable hands she's actually sympathetic, and a times hilarious with a twisted, deadpan sense of humor. Part of the our attachment to her may stem from what Sophie Nélisse does as the teen version just seeing what she went through out there. It's just not the kind of emotional trauma that heals overnight, making it easier to see why she'd be prone to these disastrous decisions.  

What hasn't changed about adult Taissa is the stubbornness, throwing herself into the public eye with a senate run that not only draws unwanted attention to the group, but compromises the safety of wife Simone (Rukiya Bernard) and their troubled young son Sammy (Aiden Stoxx). What's going on with her is viscerally disturbing and on an entirely different level than the other survivors, suggesting a full-fledged dissociative disorder of some kind. Tawny Cypress does an exceptional job conveying the growing panic of someone whose private and public personas are simultaneously unraveling. The biggest danger Taissa's family faces just might be her, and she knows it.

Few would complain if the whole series were a middle-aged Misty and Natalie buddy comedy, as their onscreen chemistry is priceless, providing Ricci and Lewis the ideal outlet for their distinctive talents. Misty is who she is, and unapologetically so. If the rest were forever changed by the crash, you get the impression she's always been like this. Thirsting for acceptance, unable to read social cues and yet strangely comfortable in her own skin, there's hardly a moment of reflection or regret for this toxic caregiver, even when leveraging others to further her agenda. Everything is a means to an end, but Ricci brilliantly imbues this painfully self-aware character with such funny, likable quirks that you can't help but want to believe good intentions could be buried beneath even her most deluded behavior. 

Misty is the ideal foil to Nat, played by a manically unhinged Juliette Lewis at the top of her game. Wildly unpredictable and constantly on the verge of substance relapse, she doesn't suffer fools, which Misty appreciates. Nat actually does seem to need her help, but isn't above above using manipulation or blackmail either, representing a stark change from the brave, resourceful girl we see in the woods in '96. It's obvious Nat's had the roughest post-crash existence, greatly contrasting with how highly she's been spoken of by Shauna and Taissa. But that was the past and this is the present. What happened in between is still largely unknown, despite an abundance of clues and bread crumbs dropped throughout.

The show's already mastered the lost art of classic opening title sequences, with Craig Wedren and Anna Waronker's theme, "No Return" seemingly arriving via time machine from the mid-90's. It's accompanied by a grungy, VHS-style assortment of obscure shots sure to have fans frantically searching for Easter eggs. And the rest of its Gen-X infused soundtrack lives up to that musical promise, featuring an onslaught of cleverly placed, period specific needle drops from the likes of The Smashing Pumpkins, The Offspring, Jane's Addiction, Hole, Collective Soul, Liz Phair, The Cranberries and Belly. 

It's hardly a spoiler to reveal that the Eduardo Sánchez-directed finale ("Sic Transit Gloria Mundi') contains multiple surprises and tragedies, as the events of 1996 continue to inform our evolving perceptions of 2021 and its current characters. The tensions between young Jackie and Shauna will have to reach a head, the repercussions of which still clearly reverberate decades later. Adult Misty's desire for control reaches alarming levels as the fragility of Taissa's mental state proves even more precarious than initially suspected. And how about the postcards and blackmail? What about Adam? But maybe more importantly, who's the Antler Queen?  

A genre mash-up of sorts, this feels like the kind of series we've been waiting for, even if it's necessary to temper those expectations with the possibility it can just as easily fly off the rails. While there have already been teases of the supernatural, it's probably too risky a proposition to build the series around it. It's been at its best when exploring the interpersonal relationships and psychological trauma resulting from the crash's aftermath. There's likely to be a continued emphasis on the mystical horror/sci-fi elements, but that tends to work better in a less literal sense, instead reflecting the characters' fractured psyches. How to balance that is a decision they'll have to make before the show can truly know what it is.

If the writers play their cards right, they can expand not just this story, but the series' entire universe. The media circus and the public obsession with the crash seems like fertile ground for future episodes, as does the eventual rescue itself, assuming that's what happens. We could also get a glimpse into what the survivors' lives were like after their return, or even further before the flight. And we'll definitely be getting more older versions of the '96 characters, only further fueling speculation.

Supposedly, the creators have a five-year plan in place, and while it's easy to imagine there's enough story to sustain that, the details will be what matter most. In the meantime, it's safe to bet on many twists and blindsides, as the series continues to show all the signs of evolving into something really special. Whether what follows is capable of sustaining its creative ambition is another matter. Either way, what comes next is anyone's guess, so it's probably just best to buckle up and prepare for a wild ride.