The Monkey

Director: Osgood Perkins
Starring: Theo James, Tatiana Maslany, Christian Convery, Colin O' Brien, Rohan Campbell, Sarah Levy, Adam Scott, Elijah Wood, Osgood Perkins, Tess Degenstein, Danica Dreyer, Laura Mennell
Running Time: 98 min.
Rating: R

★★★ (out of ★★★★)   

With barely enough time to catch our breathe and recover after his release of last year's polarizing Longlegs, writer/director Osgood Perkins returns with The Monkey, based on Stephen King's popular short story from 1985's "The Skeleton Crew." And while it's somewhat of a departure for a filmmaker whose previous horror entries have been deadly serious, signs started to emerge he could be veering closer to the mainstream with subsequent efforts. 

After showing an affinity for dark, cerebral thrillers like Se7en and Zodiac in Longlegs, Perkins' story took a turn into more conventional territory, splitting critics and audiences down the middle. This combined with one of Nic Cage's crazier performances makes it less shocking to see the director now giving us a black comedy that invokes Final Destination, Child's Play and M3GAN by way of M. Night Shyamalan. But it's also his most purely enjoyable outing, full of gruesomely macabre situations and laugh out loud moments that should cause viewers to satisfyingly squirm with discomfort.

In 1999, identical twin brothers Hal and Bill Shelburn (Christian Convery) are left to be raised by single mother Lois (Tatiana Maslany) when their father (Adam Scott) disappears after attempting to return a drum-playing toy monkey to an antique shop. But when the boys go through their dad's belongings and discover the toy, they find that the monkey causes death once its mechanical key is turned. And after their beloved babysitter is decapitated, Hal's attempt to kill his bullying brother backfires when he realizes the monkey doesn't take requests, leaving them motherless and under the guardianship of kooky aunt Ida (Sarah Levy) and uncle Chip (Perkins).

Now twenty-five years after the monkey's presumed disposal, Hal and Bill (Theo James) are estranged, with Hal rarely seeing his own teen son Petey (Colin O' Brien) in an effort to protect him from the toy's potential return. But when a freak accident draws him back to his childhood home in Maine, it's clear the monkey's back to claim a new cluster of innocent victims. Reconnecting with Bill, Hal must find a way to stop this while protecting a son who assumes his dad wants nothing to do with him. Only when the family finally comes to terms with their shared, sordid past can they possibly put an end to the destruction.

In a lengthy but gripping prologue, the monkey is introduced via a hysterically unhinged Adam Scott performance as the twins' father, shaken to his core in attempting to rid himself of what he warns the store's owner isn't a "toy." This blood-soaked scenario perfectly sets the stage for what follows, as its the first of many elaborately staged monkey kills that tie into the film's central theme of not knowing when anyone's time is up, an idea imparted on the twins by their cynical, bracingly honest mom Lois. 

The opening section works overtime in establishing the uneasy dynamic between siblings who Convery gives two very distinct personalities, especially with his depiction of Bill as an insufferable, bullying teen we want to see get his comeuppance. And Maslany makes a huge impact with limited screen time, her character leaving an impression on the twins that lingers long after the prologue ends. She's also at the center of the film's most chilling moment, with Perkins knowing that for as many over-the-top, jaw dropping deaths there are, hers needs to be played terrifyingly straight.  

Once the action shifts into the present and reluctant father Hal attempts to shield Petey from the monkey, things get pretty wild, as the doll causes continuous carnage with its randomly sadistic murders, most notably an electrifying one at a hotel pool. But the most impressive aspect of all this insanity is how firm a grasp Perkins has on tone, infusing often ludicrous scenes with Hal's lingering guilt, which is magnified by the twin he still resents and a son he's pushed away.

After seemingly falling off the movie radar for years, Divergent series star Theo James pulls off a Josh Hartnett inspired comeback to portray adult Hal as a dad too imprisoned by his mistakes to forge a real relationship with anyone until catastrophe intervenes. He's also resonates equally as the smug, slimy Bill, whose preoccupation with avenging their mother's death decades earlier carries lethal consequences. We also get some humorous turns from Elijah Wood as a self-help parenting guru married to Hal's ex-wife and Halloween Ends' Rohan Campbell (in a hilarious wig) as a local metalhead who comes into possession of the cursed toy. 

Visually striking and atmospheric, there's a sense of sinister, pessimistic dread that's driven home with an occasionally powerful message about death and childhood trauma. The events are over-the-top, but presented in such a way that you'll feel and fear the cruel hand of fate behind each kill. Despite minor faults accompanying a busy final act, it's hard to imagine King himself being dissatisfied, especially when compared to lesser cinematic interpretations of his work. Those still anxiously waiting for Perkins to take his talent to the next level may have to wait a little longer, but as a fun, skillfully made diversion, The Monkey checks just about every box.